Stache n' Scale

Case Study

CASE_STUDY: 009 · PAWP · Affiliate

Scaling Affiliate for Membership Quality

As Growth Marketing Lead at PAWP, I rebuilt affiliate the way I had at Funimation: measured the LTV of each partner's traffic, grew partnerships 30%, lifted affiliate-driven new subscriptions 25% with tailored promotions, and helped pull overall CAC down 30%.

-30% Overall CAC


Affiliate Volume Without Membership Quality

PAWP's affiliate channel brought traffic, but too much of it failed to become high-quality memberships. Platform costs and partner economics were hard to defend when CAC kept climbing.

I inherited the same class of problem I had solved at Funimation: a channel that looked active on paper, but needed an audit, a broader partner mix, clearer attribution, and a way to measure the LTV of each partner's traffic so we scaled quality, not just volume.

  • THIN PARTNER MIX
  • OPAQUE ATTRIBUTION
  • WEAK PROMOTIONS
  • CAC PRESSURE

Auditing Partners, Costs, and Credit

Before expanding the roster, I mapped which partners earned memberships worth keeping, where fees and attribution leaked value, and what LTV each partner's traffic actually produced over time.

Partner & Commission Audit

Reviewed active partners, commission structures, and membership conversion paths to separate quality trials from traffic that inflated CAC before LTV could justify the spend.

Platform Cost Analysis

Quantified platform fees against partner output so leadership could see where spend bought volume without membership quality.

Attribution Gap Analysis

Mapped broken tracking, overlapping windows, and disputed credit across trial and paid membership before changing partner rules.

Portfolio Segmentation

Segmented the roster by partner type, trial quality, and paid conversion so growth was not capped on a narrow creator-only mix.

Partner Traffic LTV

Measured the lifetime value of members acquired through each affiliate so partners were ranked by the long-term value of their traffic, not clicks, trials, or short-window conversions alone.

Executive Alignment

Reframed affiliate as a measurable acquisition channel with forecasts leadership could fund alongside CRO and SEO.


Growing Partnerships Beyond a Thin Roster

Partnerships grew 30% by expanding beyond a thin creator set into publishers and partners who could send high-intent pet parents into membership offers.

  1. 01

    Pet & Parenting Publishers

    Activated editorial and community publishers already trusted by pet parents, not just one-off creator posts.

  2. 02

    Deal & Offer Partners

    Brought in deal and promotion partners aligned with trial and membership offers that could convert with clearer intent.

  3. 03

    Inbound Partner Pipeline

    Built application and qualification workflows so new partners could join without waiting on fully manual outreach.

  4. 04

    Outbound Partner Development

    Prospected publishers and communities that matched PAWP's audience but were not yet in the program.

  5. 05

    Quality Gatekeeping

    Kept low-quality volume out so the larger roster still protected CAC instead of recreating the old leak.


Tailored Promotions, Incentives, and Trust

Stronger partnerships only compound when promotions and credit follow LTV. Tailored offers and incentives lifted affiliate-driven new subscriptions 25% while overall CAC moved down 30%.

PROMOTIONS INCENTIVES ATTRIBUTION LTV

Tailored Partner Promotions

Built partner-specific offers and messaging so promotions matched audience intent instead of one generic membership CTA.

Performance Incentives

Reworked compensation so partners earning quality memberships had room to grow without constant renegotiation.

LTV-Weighted Partner Economics

Weighted commissions and promotions toward partners whose traffic produced stronger membership LTV, so the channel paid for durable value instead of raw volume.

Transparent Attribution

Revised reporting so partners could see how traffic moved through trial and paid membership.

More Partners, More Subscriptions, Lower CAC

-30%

OVERALL CAC

Affiliate stopped acting like a traffic side channel and started contributing measurable membership growth. Partnerships expanded, subscription volume through the channel rose, overall CAC fell, and partners were judged by the LTV of the traffic they sent.

+30%

AFFILIATE PARTNERSHIPS

Roster growth through publisher expansion and partner development. Partners ranked by membership LTV from their traffic.

+25%

AFFILIATE SUBSCRIPTIONS

New subscription growth via stronger partnerships and tailored promotions.

-30%

OVERALL CAC

Overall acquisition cost down while affiliate quality scaled.

The calling point was LTV. Once we measured the lifetime value of each affiliate partner's traffic, we knew which partnerships to grow, which promotions to fund, and how to cut CAC without starving the channel. Partnerships up 30%, affiliate subscriptions up 25%, overall CAC down 30%.

— Growth Marketing Lead — PAWP

Scaling affiliates without knowing partner LTV?

I measure the lifetime value of each partner's traffic, grow the roster that compounds, and build promotions that scale subscriptions without inflating CAC.

Let's Connect · View More Case Studies